Shabana Mahmood received varied feedback from Labour MPs when presenting her proposed asylum reforms in the House of Commons.
The Home Secretary emphasized that a series of measures would safeguard the asylum system for future generations. Key proposals include establishing a new tribunal system where decisions would be made by the public rather than judges.
Outlined in the Immigration and Asylum Bill are provisions to impose a means-tested charge of approximately £10,000 on successful asylum seekers. The bill also aims to limit grounds for appeal regarding the right to family life and discourage last-minute appeals based on claims of modern slavery.
Before a vote on the bill, Prime Minister-in-waiting Andy Burnham’s team announced their support for the legislation.
Diane Abbott, a suspended Labour veteran, expressed skepticism, citing numerous historical immigration-related legislative changes and their failure to deliver promised fairness. She highlighted the positive contributions made by immigrants and asylum seekers in the country.
Shabana Mahmood defended her reforms, stating that without action, the asylum system would face challenges in the future. She stressed the importance of restoring fairness in the asylum process for both refugees and existing communities supporting them.
In response to demands for more safe routes for refugees, Ms. Mahmood pledged to introduce new capped safe and legal routes that would allow communities, universities, and businesses to sponsor refugees for integration and contribution to society.
Following a letter from 80 Labour MPs urging Andy Burnham to reconsider extending the wait time for indefinite leave to remain (ILR), a decision on the matter is anticipated in the autumn.
A spokesperson for Mr. Burnham emphasized the need for a compassionate yet credible asylum system that addresses illegal crossings while strengthening safe and legal pathways for genuine refugees, ensuring fairness for both asylum seekers and the welcoming communities.

