Shabana Mahmood faces criticism from England’s Children’s Commissioner over her proposed changes to asylum policies, which are deemed harmful to children. Dame Rachel de Souza has raised concerns to the Home Secretary about plans that could force families, including children receiving medical treatment, to leave the UK. Additionally, measures such as withdrawing housing and financial support from failed asylum seekers are being considered.
The Home Office is seeking input on the level of force that officers can use during deportations, potentially including handcuffing children as a last resort. Dame Rachel has called for transparency on the number of children affected by these proposals, estimating around 27,000 youngsters could be impacted if implemented.
While the government aims to reduce illegal migration through these reforms, critics argue that the plans could leave families with children in dire situations and put them at risk. Concerns are raised about potential harm to children, particularly those in need of ongoing medical care, and the sudden loss of support due to their asylum status.
Dame Rachel emphasizes the need to prioritize children’s well-being in decision-making processes and urges a reversal of proposals that disregard the importance of ongoing medical treatment as a barrier to deportation. She also opposes granting Immigration and Detainee Custody Officers the authority to use force against children.
In response to the feedback, a Home Office spokesperson stated that they are reviewing all input received during the consultation period. They affirm the commitment to providing sanctuary to those genuinely in need, while ensuring proper safeguards for children in the context of enforced family returns.

