Lawyers representing the prosecution and defense revisited the courtroom to present revised sentencing recommendations in Rodney Constantine’s case after a judge deemed their initial proposal of four years in prison inadequate. Judge Bruce Short expressed dissatisfaction with the leniency of the previous suggestion, considering Constantine’s lack of remorse for causing a fatal drunk driving accident.
Crown prosecutor Deidre Badcock and defense attorney Dan Furey returned to provincial court with an extended recommendation of five years. Badcock emphasized that this adjustment aimed to provide closure for the victim’s family and prevent further delays through potential appeals.
The court learned that Constantine was driving at high speeds between 125 and 165 km/h after consuming 15 drinks on December 10, 2023, in St. John’s. The tragic incident resulted in a crash into a house on Empire Avenue, leading to the death of passenger Mark Squires while Constantine and another passenger, Andrew Squires, sustained injuries.
Both legal representatives justified their stance on a five-year sentence during the court session. Badcock highlighted that the new recommendation was influenced by a negative pre-sentence report revealing Constantine’s evasive behavior and attempts to deflect responsibility onto others.
Constantine’s problematic driving history, including reckless driving incidents post-crash, was emphasized by Badcock. Judge Short previously criticized Constantine’s disregard for the consequences of his actions, indicating a lack of remorse.
The judge deferred the final decision to allow for thorough consideration of the arguments presented by both sides. The sentencing outcome, expected on October 2 at 2 p.m. NT, will be pivotal in shaping future sentencing decisions and ensuring transparency in the judicial process.
